Should Your Small Business Block AI Crawlers?

← Back to all posts

AI is changing how people find information online, and as a small business owner, you're facing a new decision: should you let AI systems access your website content, or block them entirely?

With Cloudflare's recent announcement that they're now blocking AI crawlers by default for new customers, this choice has become more prominent. But there's no one-size-fits-all answer. The right decision depends on your business model, goals, and how your customers find you.

What Are AI Crawlers and Why Does This Matter?

AI crawlers are automated programs that scan websites to collect information for AI systems like ChatGPT, Claude, Google's AI search features, and other AI-powered tools. When someone asks an AI chatbot "What’s the best CRM for a growing manufacturing company?" or "How do I improve cybersecurity for a remote workforce?", the AI draws from content it has previously crawled from websites across the internet.

The debate centers on whether businesses should allow this free access to their content, block access, or require AI companies to pay for it through programs like Cloudflare's new "Pay Per Crawl" system.

When Blocking AI Crawlers Makes Sense

You Rely on Website Traffic for Revenue

If your business model depends on people actually visiting your website, blocking AI crawlers might be the right choice. This includes:

Restaurants with online ordering: You want people to browse your full menu and place orders directly
Service providers with detailed portfolios: Potential clients need to see your full body of work, not just an AI summary
Retailers with e-commerce sites: You need customers to browse products and make purchases on your site

You Create Valuable, Original Content

If you invest significant time and resources in creating unique content, you might want to protect it:

Consultants who publish industry insights: Your expertise is your competitive advantage
Local experts who write detailed guides: Your comprehensive content should drive people to your services
Professional bloggers: You rely on ad revenue and direct traffic

You're Concerned About Accuracy

Some businesses deal with information where context and accuracy are critical:

Healthcare providers: Medical advice taken out of context could be dangerous
Legal professionals: Legal guidance requires proper disclaimers and context
Financial advisors: Investment advice needs to be presented with appropriate warnings

When Allowing AI Crawlers Can Help Your Business

You Want Maximum Discoverability

For many small businesses, being found is the biggest challenge. AI crawlers can help with:

Local service businesses: When someone asks AI "who does HVAC repair near me?", you want to be mentioned
Restaurants and cafes: AI recommendations for "best brunch spots" can drive new customers
Professional services: Being suggested as a "reliable accountant" or "experienced contractor" generates leads

You Sell Products or Services That Benefit from Recommendations

If your business thrives on word-of-mouth and recommendations:

Retail stores with unique products: AI might recommend your specialty items to shoppers
B2B service providers: When businesses ask AI for vendor recommendations, you want to be included
Software or app developers: AI can drive adoption by recommending your tools

You're Building Brand Awareness

Newer businesses often benefit from any mention:

Startups introducing new services: Exposure through AI can accelerate market awareness
Businesses expanding to new markets: AI mentions help establish credibility in new areas
Companies with innovative solutions: AI can help explain complex offerings to potential customers

The Middle Ground: Cloudflare's "Pay Per Crawl"

Cloudflare's new system offers a compromise. Instead of blocking AI entirely, participating businesses can set a price for AI access. This means:

You get compensated when AI systems use your content
Your business can still appear in AI responses
You maintain some control over how your content is used

Currently, this option is only available to select publishers, but it may expand to more businesses over time.

Making the Decision: A Simple Framework

Ask yourself these three questions:

1. How do your customers typically find you?

If through search and discovery: Consider allowing AI crawlers
If through direct visits and referrals: Blocking might make more sense

2. What's your primary business goal online?

Generate leads and awareness: Allow crawlers
Drive traffic to your website: Consider blocking
Sell products directly: Likely block

3. How unique and valuable is your content?

Highly unique, expensive to create: Consider blocking or paid access
General information that helps customers: Allow crawlers

How to Implement Your Decision

To Block AI Crawlers:

Use Cloudflare: Sign up for their service (free plans available) and enable AI crawler blocking
Update robots.txt: Add AI crawler user-agents to your robots.txt file (though this is less reliable)
Use WordPress plugins: Some security plugins offer bot blocking features

To Allow AI Crawlers:

Simply do nothing if you're not using Cloudflare
If you are using Cloudflare, make sure AI blocking is disabled in your settings

The Bottom Line

For most small businesses, the decision comes down to this: if you primarily need people to discover your business, allowing AI crawlers probably helps more than it hurts. If you need people to spend time on your website or you create highly valuable content, blocking might be worth considering.

Remember, this isn't a permanent decision. You can start by allowing AI access and see how it affects your business, then adjust your approach based on what you learn.

As AI continues to reshape how people find information online, staying flexible and monitoring the results of your choice will be key to making the most of this evolving landscape.

What's Next?

The relationship between AI and web content is still evolving rapidly. Keep an eye on:

How your website traffic changes over time
Whether your customers mention finding you through AI tools
New options from Cloudflare and other providers
How your competitors are handling AI crawler policies

The goal is to make a decision that aligns with your business objectives while remaining adaptable as the digital landscape continues to change.

Co-created with Anthropic Claude AI as part of our ongoing exploration of practical AI in content strategy.

Need help navigating AI decisions for your business? DaystarNewMedia.AI offers data readiness assessements and AI consulting and training services.

Should Your Small Business Block AI Crawlers? A Practical Guide for Website Owners